Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesStocksEarnInstitutionAI & More
Ripple Vet: SEC Called XRP a Security

Ripple Vet: SEC Called XRP a Security

UTodayUToday2026/07/14 13:15
By:UToday

Ripple Chief Technology Officer Emeritus David Schwartz has argued that the regulator repeatedly portrayed XRP itself as a security before courts rejected that position.

The discussion unfolded on X in response to former SEC attorney Marc Fagel, who argued that the agency's legal case centered on Ripple's sales of XRP rather than on the token itself.

"To prove a violation of Sec. 5, they needed to establish Ripple sold XRP as a security; and they say exactly that," Fagel wrote. "They might have to take that on when suing exchanges, but not here." 

Schwartz disagreed, accusing Fagel of oversimplifying the SEC's position.

"I agree. The problem is that you are falsely characterizing the argument they are making as a different argument they are not making."

He specifically challenged Fagel's assertion that "their only legal argument was that Ripple sold it as a security." "But that's not true," Schwartz said. "You are ignoring the entire thrust of their argument, their statements around it, and the pushback they got from the court. This is an attempt at completely rewriting history."

According to Schwartz, the SEC's public messaging and legal filings went well beyond alleging that Ripple conducted unregistered securities offerings.

"The complaint itself frequently refers to XRP itself as the security. The SEC's press release frequently refers to XRP itself as the security," he wrote.

Fagel acknowledged that the SEC's messaging may not have always reflected the nuances of its legal arguments.

"I'm not defending what I think was a lack of nuance in how the SEC framed its legal theories; it certainly felt like their points evolved over time," Fagel said. "But ultimately the Ripple case came down to whether it sold XRP as securities."

Schwartz countered that this framing overlooks what he considers one of Ripple's biggest courtroom victories.

"Right, but let's not forget that's because the courts soundly rejected the SEC's arguments (both to the courts and to the public) to the contrary," he wrote. "That was, correctly, understood to be a substantial victory at the time."

 A three-year anniversary 

The exchange revisits one of the central issues surrounding the SEC's 2020 lawsuit against Ripple. Three years ago, U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres ruled that Ripple's programmatic sales of XRP on public exchanges did not constitute securities transactions, while institutional sales of XRP to sophisticated investors did violate federal securities laws. 

The mixed ruling was widely viewed as a partial victory for Ripple.

The decision held that XRP itself is not a security and found that Ripple's programmatic sales of XRP on public exchanges did not constitute securities transactions. Judge Torres reasoned that retail buyers on secondary markets could not have known they were purchasing tokens from Ripple and therefore lacked a reasonable expectation of profits based on Ripple's efforts under the Howey Test.

0
0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

Understand the market, then trade.
Bitget offers one-stop trading for cryptocurrencies, stocks, and gold.
Trade now!

You may also like

The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.

Goldman Sachs' head of trading believes the current US stock market is repeating the scenario of late 2018, with monetary tightening and equity market pressure. The Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index has tightened by about 8 points in two weeks, reaching the highest level in a year. The selloff has broadened from tech stocks to defensive sectors. Gold and equities are declining simultaneously, possibly indicating investors are selling assets to raise cash, making gold a key indicator for observing liquidity stress.

华尔街见闻•2026/11/21 05:31
The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.

Goldman Sachs Trader “Revisits the 2018 Playbook”: Still Clearly Remembers “On December 24th, Clients Asked Why the Market Dropped So Much—And I Had No Idea”

Brian Garrett pointed out that the current adjustment in the US stock market is similar to the sharp decline in Q4 2018: the S&P 500 has already experienced 42% of the corresponding drop, and the VIX is approaching its peak just before Christmas. If history repeats itself, the bottom of this cycle may appear in January next year. However, the credit market and Federal Reserve policy have yet to provide clear signals of a bottom.

华尔街见闻•2026/11/21 03:51

Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis

On November 20th, Eastern Time, on its second day of trading, Anthropic's intraday price dropped to a low of $83.05, just 5 cents above the offering price of $83, and finally closed at $88.91, a decline of 8.50%. On the same day, the company's mathematician Levant Alperg announced on his personal website that he and Claude had found a candidate proof for the Riemann hypothesis, which has puzzled the mathematics community for 167 years, and released about 17 million lines of Lean formalized code.

智通财经•2026/11/21 03:21
Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis

As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.

According to Rentrak data, the global box office of "Grand Theft Auto VI" has also surpassed that of "Avengers: Endgame," the highest-grossing film of all time, which has a global box office of approximately $2.94 billion.

智通财经•2026/11/21 02:41
As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.