Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesStocksEarnInstitutionAI & More
'This is a lot': Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm's fate is unclear, judge says

'This is a lot': Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm's fate is unclear, judge says

The BlockThe Block2026/04/09 18:45
By:The Block

Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm and the Department of Justice faced off in court on Thursday to argue over whether a previous money transmitting conviction should be thrown out.

On Thursday, in a U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York courtroom in Manhattan, Judge Katherine Polk Failla heard from both sides, particularly in areas around whether Storm should have blocked transactions or shut down Tornado Cash when he knew that bad actors were using it to launder money and evade sanctions.

Failla told the parties not to read too much into her questions, adding that if she had made up her mind already, there wouldn't have been a hearing on Thursday.

"This is a lot," Failla said toward the end of the hearing, adding that she would sit with the arguments.

In August, Storm was found guilty on a money transmitting charge, but the jury could not come to a conclusion on a money laundering charge and another related to sanctions. Tornado Cash is a decentralized crypto mixing service designed to provide privacy for its users, and prosecutors say it was used by criminals and sanctioned organizations.

Since the verdict, crypto advocates have rallied behind Storm to get an appeal. Storm's case began during the Biden administration. During the Trump administration, a statement was made by Matthew J Galeotti, acting assistant attorney general of the Justice Department's Criminal Division, where he said "writing code" is not a crime.

Lawmakers down in Washington are working on adding provisions in a broader market structure bill to protect developers and clarify that non-custodial developers are not money transmitters.

In March, prosecutors asked for a retrial later this year to resolve the two other charges — the ones related to sanctions and money laundering.

What was Storm liable for?

On Thursday, the government's lawyer argued that Storm made improvements and updates to Tornado Cash, which they say helped criminals launder funds, and in turn also made him profitable.

The judge at one point asked if there could be a comparison drawn to Windows, which makes updates, but that improvements can be beneficial for both good and bad actors.

Meanwhile, Storm's lawyers continually argued that creating a crypto mixing service is not illegal and said Storm did not build Tornado Cash to be used to break the law. They argued that if the technology is legal, then upgrades should be able to be made because it's used by more than just criminals.

At a separate point, the government lawyer also drew an audible gasp from some in the courtroom after he suggested funds that were mixed with criminal funds as part of the mixing service could also be held liable.

A few of the participants felt he was bridging to assume that users of crypto mixers didn't have a legitimate reason to want to use privacy-preserving protocols, "which is absurd," someone in the courtroom told The Block.

Throughout the hearing, Storm propped his head up in his palm, listening to the arguments.

Amanda Tuminelli, chief legal officer at the DeFi Education Fund, who sat at the hearing, said that the government does not understand the underlying technology.

"The lack of nuance, the misrepresentations about how a UI [user interface] functions, and the equivocation between different technologies is really disheartening at this point in the case," she said in a statement.

At the end of the hearing, Failla floated the next dates for a hearing, which Tuminelli said she sees as leaning toward a retrial.

"It was good to see the judge digging in and asking detailed questions, but there is no way to predict how she will rule on Storm's motion," Tuminelli said. "Given that she was focused on dates for the retrial at the end of the hearing, I think we can expect to see the case continue."


0
0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

Understand the market, then trade.
Bitget offers one-stop trading for cryptocurrencies, stocks, and gold.
Trade now!

You may also like

The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.

Goldman Sachs' head of trading believes the current US stock market is repeating the scenario of late 2018, with monetary tightening and equity market pressure. The Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index has tightened by about 8 points in two weeks, reaching the highest level in a year. The selloff has broadened from tech stocks to defensive sectors. Gold and equities are declining simultaneously, possibly indicating investors are selling assets to raise cash, making gold a key indicator for observing liquidity stress.

华尔街见闻•2026/11/21 05:31
The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.

Goldman Sachs Trader “Revisits the 2018 Playbook”: Still Clearly Remembers “On December 24th, Clients Asked Why the Market Dropped So Much—And I Had No Idea”

Brian Garrett pointed out that the current adjustment in the US stock market is similar to the sharp decline in Q4 2018: the S&P 500 has already experienced 42% of the corresponding drop, and the VIX is approaching its peak just before Christmas. If history repeats itself, the bottom of this cycle may appear in January next year. However, the credit market and Federal Reserve policy have yet to provide clear signals of a bottom.

华尔街见闻•2026/11/21 03:51

Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis

On November 20th, Eastern Time, on its second day of trading, Anthropic's intraday price dropped to a low of $83.05, just 5 cents above the offering price of $83, and finally closed at $88.91, a decline of 8.50%. On the same day, the company's mathematician Levant Alperg announced on his personal website that he and Claude had found a candidate proof for the Riemann hypothesis, which has puzzled the mathematics community for 167 years, and released about 17 million lines of Lean formalized code.

智通财经•2026/11/21 03:21
Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis

As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.

According to Rentrak data, the global box office of "Grand Theft Auto VI" has also surpassed that of "Avengers: Endgame," the highest-grossing film of all time, which has a global box office of approximately $2.94 billion.

智通财经•2026/11/21 02:41
As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.