French Prosecutors Investigate Nestlé, Danone and Other Companies Over Contaminated Infant Formula
Key Points
- The Paris prosecutor's office announced on Friday that it has launched an investigation into five infant formula manufacturers.
- Prior to this investigation, related products had been recalled globally after cereulide was detected in infant food, causing significant concern among parents and investors.
- The “precautionary recall” initially launched by Nestlé has continued to escalate, now affecting over 60 countries and impacting flagship brands such as Aptamil, Cow & Gate, and SMA.
In recent weeks, the crisis triggered by contaminated infant formula has intensified, with wave after wave of product recalls. On Friday, the Paris prosecutor's office announced the initiation of an investigation into five infant formula manufacturers, leaving parents and investors anxious.
The companies under investigation include the world's three largest dairy groups:
Nestlé, Danone, and the privately held Lactalis, as well as smaller brands Babybio and La Marque en Moins.
The recall was due to possible contamination of products with cereulide. This is a heat-resistant toxin that can cause nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea if consumed; symptoms usually subside within a day, but more severe complications are possible.
The Paris prosecutor's office stated that the investigation concerns the “sale of substandard goods harmful to human health.” The maximum penalty for this offense is 7 years in prison, along with a fine of up to 3.75 million euros (about 4.45 million US dollars). CNBC has contacted the companies involved for comment.
In January of this year, Nestlé CEO Philippe Navratil apologized for the concerns and distress this incident has caused parents and consumers.
“I assure you that your safety and health are our top priorities,” he said.
The prosecutor's office stated that, due to the large number of complaints nationwide, it has formally intervened in the case.
In addition, the French Ministry of Health is investigating three reports of infant deaths, all of whom had consumed formula included in this recall.
On February 11, the Ministry of Health stated that no causal relationship has yet been established and the judicial investigation is still ongoing.
Global Recall
On January 29, Nestlé released an “incident timeline” stating that traces of cereulide were detected in some finished product batches at its Dutch factory in early December.
On December 10, the company notified the Dutch authorities, the European Commission, and potentially affected countries of the risk, and initiated a recall the same day, involving 25 products in 16 European countries.
In January, the Swiss company publicly announced a large-scale recall in Europe of brands such as SMA, Beba, and Little Steps for the first time.
French peers Danone (manufacturer of Aptamil and Cow & Gate) and Lactalis subsequently issued their own recalls.
To date, over 60 countries have issued recall notices.
Nestlé stated that the source of the contamination has been traced to a supplier of arachidonic acid (ARA) oil, an ingredient commonly added to infant formula.
Because multiple companies and brands used this supplier, the crisis has continued to expand. The supplier involved has not yet been officially named. The UK's Food Standards Agency stated that Nestlé and Danone have ceased using this ARA oil supplier.
Authorities continue to remind parents and caregivers to check whether the formula milk powder at home belongs to the recalled batches.
On February 2, the European Food Safety Authority set a safety threshold for cereulide. Barclays analyst Warren Ackman noted that because this toxin is rare, there was previously no unified standard.
Earlier this month, UK authorities said they had received at least 36 clinical reports of infants presenting with symptoms consistent with cereulide poisoning.
Nestlé and Danone to Announce Financial Results This Week
Infant formula accounts for about 5% of Nestlé's total revenue, with the company disclosing that the recalled products represent only about 0.5% of its revenue.
“Given consumer confusion and brand risk, the larger 5% figure is more meaningful as a reference,” said Bernstein analyst Callum Elliott in January.
“For Danone, infant formula is more important—we estimate it accounts for about 21% of group revenue, with an even higher contribution to profits.”
Both Nestlé and Danone are scheduled to release their financial results later this week, and investors are hoping for greater clarity on the financial impact of the recall event.
Stock Market Performance
Since the beginning of this year, affected by the formula recall, the share prices of Nestlé and Danone have underperformed the European benchmark index.
Investors worry about financial losses and damage to brand reputation:
- Nestlé year-to-date increase: 1.7%
- Danone year-to-date decline: 5.5%
- European Stoxx 600 Index increase for the same period: 4.6%
Both stocks fell sharply at the end of January during the peak recall period, but have since rebounded somewhat.
Editor: Guo Mingyu
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.
Goldman Sachs' head of trading believes the current US stock market is repeating the scenario of late 2018, with monetary tightening and equity market pressure. The Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index has tightened by about 8 points in two weeks, reaching the highest level in a year. The selloff has broadened from tech stocks to defensive sectors. Gold and equities are declining simultaneously, possibly indicating investors are selling assets to raise cash, making gold a key indicator for observing liquidity stress.

Goldman Sachs Trader “Revisits the 2018 Playbook”: Still Clearly Remembers “On December 24th, Clients Asked Why the Market Dropped So Much—And I Had No Idea”
Brian Garrett pointed out that the current adjustment in the US stock market is similar to the sharp decline in Q4 2018: the S&P 500 has already experienced 42% of the corresponding drop, and the VIX is approaching its peak just before Christmas. If history repeats itself, the bottom of this cycle may appear in January next year. However, the credit market and Federal Reserve policy have yet to provide clear signals of a bottom.
Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis
On November 20th, Eastern Time, on its second day of trading, Anthropic's intraday price dropped to a low of $83.05, just 5 cents above the offering price of $83, and finally closed at $88.91, a decline of 8.50%. On the same day, the company's mathematician Levant Alperg announced on his personal website that he and Claude had found a candidate proof for the Riemann hypothesis, which has puzzled the mathematics community for 167 years, and released about 17 million lines of Lean formalized code.

As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.
According to Rentrak data, the global box office of "Grand Theft Auto VI" has also surpassed that of "Avengers: Endgame," the highest-grossing film of all time, which has a global box office of approximately $2.94 billion.

