When Bitcoin Splits into Sects: Developers Wage a Holy War Over “What Should Go Into a Block”
The Bitcoin community is facing internal division over the purpose of the blockchain, with the core controversy centered on whether to modify the code to accommodate more non-financial transaction data. The Core camp supports relaxing restrictions to expand use cases and increase miner revenue, while the Knots camp opposes this and has launched its own client software. Summary generated by Mars AI. This summary is generated by the Mars AI model, and the accuracy and completeness of its content are still in the process of iterative updates.
Bitcoin is facing a new civil war over the use of its blockchain
I recently had the pleasure of visiting the charming Swiss mountain town of Lugano. Its appeal lies in the fact—as Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino put it—that the city is “essentially Italian, but managed by the Swiss.” Ardoino is one of the main backers of the “Plan B” Bitcoin conference, where I moderated a discussion about the growing trend of governments around the world embracing this original cryptocurrency.
The atmosphere at the conference was upbeat—which is no surprise, since everyone present worships Bitcoin—but it was also clear that trouble lurks in paradise. It turns out that Bitcoin’s codebase is experiencing an increasingly deep division: the controversy centers on whether the code should be modified to allow the blockchain to accommodate more data unrelated to financial transactions.
The idea of including non-Bitcoin transaction-related data in blocks is not new. In fact, the very first block on the blockchain included a newspaper headline about a bank bailout. However, today, Bitcoin’s largest and most influential group of developers—known as “Core”—plans to adjust their software to significantly relax the restrictions on the amount of non-payment information that can be included in each block.
For the Core camp, this is a simple and pragmatic move that can both promote new uses for Bitcoin and create additional fee income for miners at a time when the block reward is only 3.125 bitcoins and is expected to halve again in 2028. However, a rapidly rising rival faction completely rejects this plan and has launched their own Bitcoin client software—Knots.
This faction’s software is led by an influential Bitcoin developer who is a devout Catholic and reportedly named it “Knots” after the story of Jesus driving out the money changers from the temple with a “whip of cords.” According to a lawyer from the Knots camp whom I interviewed, the necessity of this software lies in protecting the blockchain from what he condemns as spam senders and those promoting “borderline scam” projects such as Bitcoin NFTs.
If you have ever interacted with Bitcoin supporters online or offline, you know they are not known for their diplomacy. This is especially true of early prominent figures in Bitcoin—they attacked each other both on the stage in Lugano and on X (formerly Twitter). These high-profile camp representatives include: Peter Todd and Jameson Lopp from the Core camp, and Nick Szabo and Luke Dashjr from the opposing Knots camp.
This latest split (a useful overview can be read here) is reminiscent of the “block size war” that swept the entire Bitcoin community from 2015 to 2017. At that time, the “small block” faction—those who advocated keeping Bitcoin blocks at 1MB—ultimately defeated their opponents who believed that expanding to 2MB or larger was commercially viable. The resentment left by that war lingers to this day.
In the current struggle, Knots remains the smaller faction, but it has become the preferred client for more than 20% of Bitcoin node operators. Its rapid popularity is not only due to its stance on blockchain expansion issues, but also because of the widespread perception that the Core camp has become arrogant and detached from Bitcoin’s core values. The Core camp, in turn, dismisses the Knots faction as “lying troublemakers.”
I am not in a position to judge, but I can point out: this latest battle for Bitcoin’s soul once again confirms my long-held view—Bitcoin is both a remarkable technology and a religion. As with any religion, there will always be splits between conservative believers and modernists. Fortunately, there was also a moment of unity at the Lugano venue: that was at the lakeside unveiling of the restored Satoshi Nakamoto statue. Although the various Bitcoin factions are at war, there is no doubt that they still worship the same god.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.
Goldman Sachs' head of trading believes the current US stock market is repeating the scenario of late 2018, with monetary tightening and equity market pressure. The Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index has tightened by about 8 points in two weeks, reaching the highest level in a year. The selloff has broadened from tech stocks to defensive sectors. Gold and equities are declining simultaneously, possibly indicating investors are selling assets to raise cash, making gold a key indicator for observing liquidity stress.

Goldman Sachs Trader “Revisits the 2018 Playbook”: Still Clearly Remembers “On December 24th, Clients Asked Why the Market Dropped So Much—And I Had No Idea”
Brian Garrett pointed out that the current adjustment in the US stock market is similar to the sharp decline in Q4 2018: the S&P 500 has already experienced 42% of the corresponding drop, and the VIX is approaching its peak just before Christmas. If history repeats itself, the bottom of this cycle may appear in January next year. However, the credit market and Federal Reserve policy have yet to provide clear signals of a bottom.
Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis
On November 20th, Eastern Time, on its second day of trading, Anthropic's intraday price dropped to a low of $83.05, just 5 cents above the offering price of $83, and finally closed at $88.91, a decline of 8.50%. On the same day, the company's mathematician Levant Alperg announced on his personal website that he and Claude had found a candidate proof for the Riemann hypothesis, which has puzzled the mathematics community for 167 years, and released about 17 million lines of Lean formalized code.

As US stocks plummet, the parent company of GTA 6 rises against the market! First-day sales hit a record $3.79 billion; Wall Street shifts focus to next-generation GTA Online.
According to Rentrak data, the global box office of "Grand Theft Auto VI" has also surpassed that of "Avengers: Endgame," the highest-grossing film of all time, which has a global box office of approximately $2.94 billion.

